This is an interesting idea. Thanks for sharing it. But I’m not inclined to advise the HOA on something not clearly stated by FinCEN in their FAQ’s as acceptable. Too many risks if the advice is later found to be wrong, and not enough time before Dec 31, 2024 to thoroughly consider it.
Incidentally, the presenter said current estimated compliance by state ranges between 6% and 24%, as I recall. That could mean the system is going to get overloaded and slow down to a crawl or even seize up in the coming weeks.
He also raised some troubling scenarios if IRS puts a question on the tax return 2-3 years from now (similar to the Foreign Accounts question on Schedule B. Might create some problems for tax preparers who had not documented that they advised their clients of the requirement this year.