Option 1 is viable as long as it was intended to be a loan and loan documents were drawn up. Option 2 is viable if taking the money was disguised wages. Option 3 is viable since that is what it probably really is. No deduction to the corp for this. Not sure I understand option 4. The corp would pay tax on the money under option 1 and 3 anyway. Absent loan docs, I would probably opt for a combination of options 2 and 3 unless the shareholder is already taking a fair wage; or unless the shareholder is not entitled to a wage, I,e, he did not work for the corp.