Tom, Was the payment listed as non-employee comp on the 1099? Years ago, my late husband and I had a house "offered" to us by a banker who was going to use the short-sale as a way to make money for himself also. Did you see the "short sell" document? Is the selling price too good to be true? If it is, we all know about such things. Is it possible that $18,800 was slipped under the table and split with your client and the banker? A payment ($9,400) under $10,000 can be questionable. Before you ask, no, we didn't buy the home because of the "scheme" that really sickened us more than anything. And, just maybe your client's situation is legit, however, don't know if it's the lingering smell of our deal or the smell of your's client's deal....but I definitely smell something fishy! Take care, Paranoid Cathy