Some time ago I prepared taxes for a hairdresser who owned her own shop, and had another hairdresser pay her "chair rent". She didn't really have much in records to support either revenue or expense but we did the best we could with a bank account. I have 6-7 other cosmetologists with varying income so I have somewhat of a grasp, but certainly not as much grasp as would have been the case with adequate records. Most hairdressers are better cosmetologists than they are record-keepers.
She ended up owing some money. She then proceeded to order me to remove revenue until her tax liability was reduced to zero.
Nope. Not this guy. Bye Bye hairdresser who owns your own shop and turns in only $150 a week.
She did have a child. A friend of hers told me earlier tonight that she found another tax preparer, and that she ended up with a $4000 refund. She and all her friends think her new tax preparer is a genius - and I am not very good at all.
Grrrr! I have found out that the IRS is much more interested in penalizing preparers than they are going after the taxpayers themselves when cheating is determined. A couple years ago, a colleague of mine called his congressman whom he personally knew. In a day or two the congressman wrote him the intent of the earned income credit was to redistribute income and that tracking down cheaters was counter to their purpose. The interception of violations is basically now upon tax preparers.
From the mass numbers I've been made aware, a good 25-50% of EIC recipients are not due, similar to my experience above. Aggressive claiming of social security numbers not entitled, social security numbers for sale on the black market, phony relatives, etc. In my county, the existence of 2-3 audits per year would scare off most of the cheaters. It is amazing how much they know about earned income credit. Yet the 8867 places all the burden on the preparer where in almost all instances, the preparer has no vehicle to be aware of violations.
You've heard all this whining before, of course. Most of you have experienced it first-hand. But where is the light at the end of the tunnel?