Thanks for all the perspectives. My particular focus was the frustration with the partial information that's floating around. People can read that the income is not considered taxable as debt forgiveness and then the article stops, or else if the article tells the whole story the client fails to read it all or "conveniently" forgets the other part. There isn't much to do other than tell them the whole story and then watch the puzzled expression on their face.
Interesting turn this conversation has taken. Accounting for the PPP loan on the tax return might be challenging in several ways, depending upon what Congress does (if anything). What about preparing an interim financial statement? Say a client needs a Sept 30, 2020 financial statement for a lender. Do we need to reduce payroll/rent expense to reflect the anticipated loan forgiveness, add a line item at the bottom of the financial statement with a title such as "Anticipated PPP loan forgiveness", or just ignore the expected loan forgiveness since it hasn't yet been processed & approved? In the last scenario the financial statement can look pretty ugly, in the first scenario it can look too rosy, but in the middle scenario there is full disclosure. This might be considered the "Goldilocks" conundrum.