jainen, I cannot believe that you think that I am making Marxist arguments. You -must- be willfully misconstruing my remarks, as I can see NO way to accidentally do so.
I believe that ALL income taxes are diametrically opposed to the intent of the Founders, and they instituted the government to very specifically NOT tax income. Part of the reason for this was to "starve" the Federal government to keep it from encroaching on the rights of the states and the people, partly because of the disincentive to strive and achieve it becomes over time. MOST of what the Federal government does today is NOT in their purview; they have taken over the work of the states and the people and usurped powers they were very specifically NOT to have. This encroachment has been going on for over a hundred years now.
I have studied the Marxist systems - both in theory and as they exist in the real world - extensively. They do NOT work. They never WILL work. The essence of Marxism is central CONTROL of ALL aspects of the lives of the people. The essence of the Declaration of Independence and the US Constitution is individual FREEDOM and individual RESPONSIBILITY. The only people who will willfully choose the former are those who believe that the control and associated power will be theirs to wield.
With every post you make, I understand more why you have been banned from other fora.